Previously reviewed on Bulldog's Bookshelf:
I'm quite surprised that I've taken NINE MONTHS off from reviewing books here on the Insanity. Just goes to show you what a busy year I've had. Having said that, I have read quite a few wrestling books over that time -- just need to find time to review them now. And for those of you who forgot (or weren't even born when the last review came out), here's a quick review of the often-imitated-but-never-duplicated
Canadian Bulldog Ratings System:
The Best There Is, The Best There Was, The Best There Ever Will Be:
Self-explanatory. This rating is reserved for my absolute favorites, ones that I could read through over and over again.
Oh Hell Yeah!:
While not the top of the line, there's enough good stuff in here to make me want to recommend it.
Not an urgent read, by any means. If you're starting up a collection, or if you're a big fan on the subject matter, go for it.
More bad than good here. Hey, if you can pick it up for a few dollars at a used bookstore or borrow it off your friend, fine. But you've been warned.
Why on earth would any publisher approve this crap? What were they thinking? Only valuable if you're the type that likes reading total and complete train-wrecks.
Benoit: Wrestling With The Horror That Destroyed A Family And Crippled A Sport
Authors: Steven Johnson, Heath McCoy, Irv Muchnick, Greg Oliver
Synopsis: Essays about the death of Chris Benoit and the shockwaves it caused throughout the wrestling industry.
Benoit cried in the dressing room, worried for his friend. He left Philadelphia that night, not knowing that Sabu's neck was all but broken. He followed up once he returned to Edmonton, calling ECW boss Paul Heyman, who was over the moon with excitement.
"It's great, you're going to be called Teh Crippler. This is awesome, we're going to make so much money," Benoit recalled Heyman telling him excitedly. All the while he just wanted to know the status of his friend. Benoit still grappled with the potentially lethal mistake years later. "Things do happen, accidents do happen. I think the people that I work with know me, and the people that know me personally know I'd never take advantage of a situation or someone in the ring like that," he said. "They know that it was a mistake. Things happen. It's a physical, contact sport, and and injuries are going to happen." Still, he would admit to liking The Crippler nickname. "It grew on me and I'm proud of it."
I have to admit, the subject matter in this book is not something I love talking about. Like many of us, I was absolutely devastated when Chris Benoit reportedly
murdered his family in 2007, before taking his own life. And I was equally shocked by the media feeding frenzy that ensued and how every Tom, Dick and Marc Mero ever associated with wrestling were using this incident to further their own agendas. I was concerned that this book served no other purpose but then to make a quick buck.
And I will also admit I was wrong.
Benoit (the book) is comprised of five short essays by known wrestling columnists, each different enough from the last to make for a very interesting read. Whether I agreed or disagreed with the points raised in the content, each essay is informative and well written. Almost five years later, the information largely holds up. There's also a comprehensive Chris Benoit championship history that covers everything from working in Stampede to his final days in WWE.
Greg Oliver, known for his Pro Wrestling Hall of Fame books and contributions to Slam! Wrestling, covers off two essays (as well as the aforementioned championship history). The first is a comprehensive biography about Benoit which also documents the struggles he had in later years (namely coping with the loss of many of his friends). Oliver also includes an email sent to him personally by Benoit shortly after Eddie Guerrero's death. The message is telling and almost worth the price of the book alone.
Oliver's second essay is dedicated to Nancy Toffoloni (a/k/a Fallen Angel, Woman, Nancy Sullivan and Nancy Benoit) and a look at her long career inside and outside of professional wrestling. It's a story that isn't nearly as well-known as her former husband's, and needs to be told. Kudos to Oliver for getting past the Cliffs Notes version of who she is and providing some proper context.
The third essay is written by Heath McCoy, a Calgary-based reporter who put together the phenomenal Pain and Passion biography of Stampede Wrestling and the Hart Family. His story, of course, looks at Benoit's Stampede career, the unusual relationship he shared with Dynamite Kid, how people like Bad News Allen and Bruce Hart shaped his career and how his transformation from scrawny fanboy to Stampede wrestler upset some of the locker room. There's nothing earth-shattering or ground-breaking here, but it does make for a good story.
The fourth essay is from Stephen Johnson (also of the Pro Wrestling Hall of Fame books) and is perhaps my favorite one in the book. The story analyzes how the mainstream media dealt with the Benoit tragedies, what kind of ratings their "reporting" got them and how everyone on the fringes of the wrestling industry tried to get in on the action. Johnson addresses how often Geraldo Rivera, Nancy Grace and, yes, even Linda McMahon perpetuated silly rumors instead of sticking to the facts. He also gets comments from wrestling journalists such as Dave Meltzer, who described his behind-the-scenes role in helping inform television talking heads.
The final essay is written by Irv Muchnick, an author and columnist who specializes in prof wrestling scandals and sports concussions (he's also the nephew of legendary NWA promoter Sam Muchnick). His story is, somewhat predictably, about how the Benoit tragedy personifies the very worst in an industry of con men, flim flam artists and shysters (well, it does have Irwin R). While we'll never know what prompted Benoit to do what we did, Muchnick argues, the so-called "wrestling lifestyle" undoubtedly played a part in it.
How do I feel about this? To be honest, I'm less opposed to his essay than you'd think. Unlike a certain newsletter/website (some of you know whom I'm referring to) that makes ridiculous points to garner attention, Muchnick's work is meticulously-researched and he works hard to seek out the truth. He's not afraid to contact police, researchers and other people (again, unlike a certain website) so that he has ample ammunition to make his points. And while I don't really agree with his tough take on the wrestling business, it's hard not to respect him for putting together some compelling arguments.
Overall Rating: Transitional Champion. Do wrestling fans need to read this book? Probably not. But it provides some unique insights into arguably wrestling's darkest period and Chris Benoit, and I have no problem recommending it for a read.
Canadian Bulldog (don't pretend like you don't know who he is!!!) has been writing about professional wrestling since 2003, and became a WWI Superstar at
World Wrestling Insanity
in January 2006. Need more Bulldog? Check out his "Complete and Utter Bulldog" podcast at
; like his
page and follow him on