Search
Stalk Us On Facebook Follow Us on Twitter Add Us On Myspace Grab Our RSS Feed


Insanity Readers and Staff Choose: 2005's Worst Gimmick

By World Wrestling Insanity's Readers & Staff Dec 27, 2005 - 6:30 PM

Well, the Staff and the Readers didn't agree on this one.  However, one thing was clear.  WWE's writers have been renting DVDs.  How do we know?  Well, how else do you explain the two winners of this year's voting.  First the reader results...

2005 Reader's Choice for Worst Gimmick...

The Boogeyman



2nd Place:  Kerwin White
3rd Place:   (Tie) The Dicks/Jillian Hall


Reader Comments:

"Wow, where to start? Boogeyman? Chavo Guerrerro has Kerwin White? Matt Hardy has the human punching bag? Matt Morgan has a stutterer, Simon Dean? Hassan has a terrorist?  Too many bad gimmick this year.  But I guess the absolute worst gimmick must be the Boogeyman."
- Antoine Quintal-Leonard

"The Boogeyman.  Stupid, unfunny, and just plain retarded... even if ZAH adores him."
- D. Lockard

"I wish there really was no such thing as the Boogeyman.  Not the monster - the wrestler."
- Tara Shilling



But wait, now it's time for....

2005 Insanity Staff's Choice for Worst Gimmick...

Jillian Hall



2nd Place:  Kerwin White
3rd Place:   The Dicks


"I don't understand this gimmick at all.  Maybe it's a rib on Hall, that after all the plastic surgery, dieting, etc. she put herself through for the sake of making the top roster, she gets stuck with a mole on her face.  Ha.  Funny."
- Eugene Sandow

"What's that on her face?"
- ZAH


Check back for the results of the rest of our Re ader and Staff  Awards (Wrestler of the Year, Match of the Year, and Tag Team of the Year).  Plus our the special Year End Radio Free Isanity featuring 2005's Top Five Moments of Insanity.


Got an opinion?  Stop by the Insanity Message Boards to discuss it.



blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest Headlines From This Category:

 

(25 Mins) JG's Audio Insanity: WWE Network - Are You Serious?
(39 Mins) Mike Johns' Maverick Radio: Go Hard or Go Home
(21 Mins) "Winterz Wonderland" with Jason Winterz: Broken Back Zack and JG vs. Otunga
(32 Mins) Complete and Utter Bulldog: The Royal Dissection
(25 Mins) JG's Audio Insanity: After The Royal Rumble

Powered by Disqus



JG's Ten Life Lessons I've Learned From Wrestling Commentary
JG's Ten Awful Pieces Of Official Wrestling Merchandise
JG's Ten Wrestling Characters With Undiagnosed Medical Conditions
JG's Ten Unforgettable Jobbers
JG's Ten Old School Managers For Ten Current Stars
JG's Ten Good Guy Wrestling Characters Who Would Have Been Great Heels
JG's Ten Old School Things Wrestling Got Rid Of (and No One Missed)
JG's Ten Annoying Things About Being a Wrestling Fan
James Guttman Responds to: Yahoo's Article on WrestleMania VII's Death Count
JG's Ten Wrestling Matches We Never Got To See (But Thought We Would)
JG's Ten Wrestling Bad Guys Who Were Completely Right
JG's Ten Wrestling Characters That Ended Too Soon
JG's Ten Untrue Things Your Grandmother Believes About Wrestling
JG's 25 Easy Ways To Get Instant Heat In The WWE Locker Room
JG's Ten Wrestling Villains With No Endgame
JG's Ten Insider Wrestling Terms You Shouldn't Use When Talking About Something Besides Wrestling
JG's Ten Wrestlers Your Non-Wrestling Fan Girlfriend Would Hate
JG's Ten Least Intimidating Wrestling Names
JG's Insanity Notebook: A Very Immortal Thanksgiving, King Sheamus, Extreme NXT, Nobody Pats Down Edge, and More
James Guttman Reveals...Future WWE Lists Designed To Piss Off The Fans

#FollowTheTweeter: Becky Bayless on the UFC 143 Controversy, Jay Briscoe Gambles on the Super Bowl, Kurt Angle Tweets Drunk (Again), #Professionalism, Win a Date with Rain, & More!
Canadian Bulldog Presents... Pushback: The 10 Worst Pushes In Wrestling History
This Week In WWE Vintage Collection History: Superbrawl Sunday
T.G.I.F. with Matt Dawgs: Undertaker Hair Faker, Fartin' Nattie, Metallica's Hulk Hogan Saves "The Wrestler", Jedi Ninjas, and More
Crocker! Dollar Store Meth, Jericho's Walls Are Broken Down, Animation Hulkamation, and More
SHIMMERingWarlock Presents EVOLVE 9: Gargano vs. Taylor
Canadian Bulldog Presents... The Family Smarkus II
This Week In WWE Vintage Collection History: Four Matches...Ninety Seven Wrestlers...
T.G.I.F. with Matt Dawgs: Save Johnny's Sleeping For The Rumble, Win Loser Drew, ROH vs. CHICKARA, The Church of Chael, and More
World Wrestling Insanity Breaking News Archive: TNA 24/7
Something Completely Different: A Preview of Dragon Gate USA's Open the Golden Gate iPPV, featuring Low-Ki vs. BxB Hulk, Ronin vs. The Young Bucks, & Sami Callihan vs. AR Fox
World Wrestling Insanity Breaking News Archive: 30 Amazing But True Royal Rumble Facts!

  All content contained here Copyright 2012 by James Guttman